Bluebeard is our favorite. We go there almost every date night. I recently fell in love with a cocktail there called the Galapagos. It's a spicy tequila drink with cucumber and lime. It's delicious! Dan always gets the Pendennis club, which is basically just an Old Fashioned.
We went to Rook in their new location, which is just a few blocks down from where it used to be in Fletcher Place. If you haven't been there, definitely try it out!